Observations on Theology, Culture and the Hosier family

Wednesday, 26 October 2011

HALLOWEEN

A friend in my Life Group pointed me towards these comments by John Piper about Halloween:



Apparently, some of my friend's friends were shocked by Piper's somewhat laissez faire approach to Halloween. Of course, Piper is an American, and within American culture Halloween has occupied a very different place from that which has historically been the case in the UK. A watershed for us was when the ET movie came out, and suddenly the 'Americanization' of Halloween began to happen in the UK - now it is a huge deal, at least commercially, and our shops are at the moment packed with ghoulish attire.

So what should our response be?

Well, I am inclined towards Piper's relaxed attitude on this one. I think it is an area where Christians can look very foolish when they have an overheated reaction. As I have written elsewhere, my belief in the supremacy of Christ over all things means I don't need to get in a panic about Halloween. However, as a parent, and as a Christian, I would have the following rough framework:

  • I wouldn't let my kids go out trick or treating. I don't like the way it seems to be begging for stuff, and I know that for some people (especially the elderly) it can be intimidating to have kids banging on their doors asking for sweets.
  • When other peoples kids knock on our door we give them something - not a tract about the evils of the occult, but some sweets or cake. Why? Because it is an opportunity to demonstrate grace and generosity.
  • I have pumpkins outside my front door. Not  in celebration of Halloween, but because Daughter No.4 grew them, and they look good!
  • I wish trick or treating was one habit we hadn't imported from the US!

1 comment:

Joseph Nolan said...

Very helpful post! You have saved me having to phone you and ask you about this issue. My flat mates are starting to get excited about Halloween, but I have never got involved with it before probably because of more hard-line teaching been brought up with. It looks like this is going to be a great opportunity to witness!